The Black Manhattan is a darker take on the classic Manhattan, swapping sweet vermouth for an Amaro such as Averna. It keeps the cocktail’s elegant simplicity while adding herbal, bittersweet complexity. This drink is versatile—perfect for an evening sipper, a New Year’s Eve toast, or a moody Halloween cocktail thanks to its deep amber-red hue.
What’s the Difference Between a Manhattan and a Black Manhattan?
Both cocktails are whiskey-forward and refined, but the Black Manhattan replaces sweet vermouth with an Amaro, which changes the balance and adds herbal bitterness and depth. Below is a quick comparison of the two:
Manhattan
- Base Spirit: Rye or bourbon whiskey
- Sweetener: Sweet vermouth
- Bitters: Angostura bitters
- Flavor Profile: Smooth and slightly sweet, with warming whiskey and vermouth notes
Black Manhattan
- Base Spirit: Rye whiskey (commonly)
- Sweetener: Amaro (Averna is popular)
- Bitters: Often Angostura plus orange or walnut bitters
- Flavor Profile: Bittersweet, herbal, and more layered than the classic Manhattan
In short, the Black Manhattan is a modern twist that trades vermouth’s sweetness for Amaro’s herbaceous bitterness, resulting in a richer, more complex cocktail.
Katie’s tip
If you have leftover Amaro, try it in dessert-style cocktails like a Chocolate Manhattan for a smooth, after-dinner drink.
Quick + Easy Recipes
straight to your inbox
Black Manhattan Ingredients
- 2 ounces rye whiskey
- 1 ounce Amaro (Averna recommended)
- 2 dashes bitters (Angostura, orange, walnut, or a combination)
- Luxardo or brandied cherry (for garnish)
Ingredient Tips and Substitutions
- Choose a rye you enjoy—something with a bit of spice works well.
- Averna is the classic Amaro choice, but Cynar, Montenegro, or other amaros will change the drink’s bitterness and herbal character in interesting ways.
- The cocktail’s natural color is a deep amber-red. If you need a true black appearance for a themed party, a drop or two of black food coloring will do it, though the natural tone is very appealing.
How to Make a Black Manhattan
- Add the rye, Amaro, and bitters to a mixing glass with 2–3 ice cubes and stir until well chilled.
- Strain into a chilled coupe or martini glass.
- Garnish with a Luxardo or brandied cherry and serve.
What to Serve With a Black Manhattan
Choose foods that balance or echo the cocktail’s herbal bitterness and whiskey backbone. Good pairings include:
- Charcuterie boards with aged cheeses, cured meats, and olives—salt and fat complement the drink’s bittersweet notes.
- Steak or beef sliders, where the Amaro cuts through richness.
- Dark chocolate desserts, such as truffles or a flourless chocolate cake, which pair beautifully with the cocktail’s herbal complexity.
- Grilled or roasted vegetables like charred Brussels sprouts or roasted root vegetables to highlight earthy flavors.
These options let the Black Manhattan’s depth remain the focus while creating a satisfying bite alongside the drink.
Recipe FAQs
What Is A Black Manhattan?
A Black Manhattan is a Manhattan-style cocktail that uses an Amaro in place of sweet vermouth. That substitution creates a darker, more complex flavor with herbal, bittersweet, and citrusy notes.
What Ingredients Are In A Black Manhattan?
Typical ingredients include rye or bourbon, an Amaro (Averna is common), and bitters (Angostura, orange, and/or walnut). A Luxardo cherry or orange twist makes a classic garnish.
What Type Of Whiskey Works Best?
Rye is traditional and adds spice that plays well with Amaro. Bourbon can be used for a softer, sweeter profile if preferred.
Why Is It Called A Black Manhattan?
The name refers to the darker color the cocktail takes on when Amaro replaces vermouth. It’s typically deep amber-red rather than truly black.
Can I Use Any Amaro?
Yes—different amaros change the balance of bitterness and herbal notes. Averna is popular, but Cynar, Montenegro, and others will each give a distinct result.
Recipe Pro Tips For the Best Black Manhattan
- This is a strong, spirit-forward cocktail. If it’s too intense, dilute with a splash of water or allow the ice to melt a bit while stirring.
- If you prefer more sweetness, choose a sweeter Amaro or add a small amount of Luxardo cherry juice or simple syrup to taste.
Storage and Presentation Tips
- Serve in a chilled coupe or martini glass for an elegant presentation; a rocks glass also works for a more casual pour.
- Luxardo cherries are classic; an orange twist enhances the citrus bitters.
- You can pre-mix the cocktail (without the cherry) and refrigerate it. Stir or briefly chill before serving and add the garnish just before pouring.
More Black Cocktails
Black Margarita: Easy Cocktail Recipe For Halloween!
Black Mojito: Refreshing Halloween Rum Cocktail!
Black Martini: Spooky Vodka Cocktail For Halloween!
Black Jello Shots With Vodka: Spooky Halloween Treat!
- Black Widow Cocktail
Final Thoughts
The Black Manhattan is a refined, three-ingredient cocktail with bold, herbal flavors and a dramatic color. Simple to make yet complex in taste, it’s an excellent choice for anyone who enjoys strong, sippable cocktails with an elegant presentation. Whether you serve it for a special celebration or a themed party, it’s an impressive variation on a classic.
If you enjoy deeply flavored, darker cocktails, the Black Manhattan is an easy recipe to add to your rotation.
Black Manhattan Cocktail Recipe With Averna
Equipment
- Mixing glass or any drinking glass (for stirring)
- Coupe or martini glass (chilled)
- Spoon
- Measuring jigger or liquid measuring cup
Ingredients
- 2 ounces rye whiskey
- 1 ounce Amaro (Averna recommended)
- 2 dashes bitters (Angostura, orange, or walnut)
- 1 Luxardo or brandied cherry
Instructions
-
Add all ingredients (except the cherry) into a mixing glass with 2–3 ice cubes and stir until well chilled.
-
Strain into a chilled coupe or martini glass.
-
Garnish with a Luxardo cherry and enjoy.
Notes
- Use a rye you like; a spicier rye pairs especially well.
- Averna is a popular Amaro choice; try other amaros for different herbal profiles.
- The drink is deep amber-red, not truly black. Add food coloring only if you need a jet-black look for a party.
- This cocktail is spirit-forward; dilute slightly with water or melted ice if it’s too strong.
Nutrition
Nutritional values are approximate and will vary by brands and portion sizes.
